We have decided, without ever saying so, that a serious person is a narrow one. Ask a physician about the history of medicine, an economist about the ethics of the policy he recommends, or a historian what a controlled experiment is, and you’ll often get a polite shrug and a reminder that it isn’t their field. We accept this. We even admire it, as if ignorance outside a speciality were proof of depth inside it. It is not proof of anything except that a career has been spent in one place.

The cost is higher than it looks. Knowledge in a narrow field keeps advancing, but the person holding it doesn’t advance with it. Someone can know everything about a single enzyme and still be unable to say why Galileo got in trouble with the Catholic Church, or what makes a moral argument a good one. And specialists face a practical risk they rarely like to discuss, which is that fields get superseded. The typesetter, the film-lab technician, and the programmer all possessed in-demand, critical skills until the day the thing they were expert in stopped being needed. A mind that holds nothing but a speciality has nothing to fall back on when that day comes.

What does this have to do with freethought? Everything. Freethought means refusing to accept a claim because an authority, a tradition, or a crowd says so. But you can only refuse intelligently on grounds you know. A person who has read nothing outside his discipline has to take the rest of the world on trust, because he has no means of checking it. He defers to the theologian on morality, the economist on society, and the newspaper on science, and he believes he is thinking freely. In fact he is a tourist everywhere except home. Breadth is what lets us notice when an expert who is solid in his own field starts bluffing in the next one.

That’s why the Renaissance Man ideal isn’t nostalgia. A person conversant in several fields can carry an idea from one to another, and some of the most interesting advances happen exactly there. Darwin was a naturalist, yet a key piece of his theory came from Malthus, who wrote about human populations and food supply. By Darwin’s own account he read Malthus for amusement. A specialist reading only the natural history journals would never have bothered.

There is a deeper reason as well. Each major branch of human effort pursues an ideal: science seeks truth, ethics seeks the good, and art seeks beauty, while history keeps the record of how we’re doing at all three. Ideals like these are not meant to be reached. They are pictures of something better than what we have, and they pull us forward. Follow only one and you hold a third of the picture. A scientist with no ethics builds whatever he is paid to build. A moralist with no science preaches against facts. An artist cut off from both just makes pleasant objects. A free mind has no reason to exclude any of them.

Is this realistic for ordinary people? Most of us have jobs, children, and a hundred other demands on our time and energy. Nobody is going to become Leonardo, and we needn’t try. The aim is to be an amateur in the old sense, someone who pursues a subject for the love of it. Amateurs have a good record. In 1727 Benjamin Franklin, then a young printer, gathered a dozen or so tradesmen in Philadelphia into a club called the Junto. They met on Friday evenings to discuss morals, politics, and natural philosophy, and to criticise each other’s essays. The club grew a subscription library, and Franklin later founded the American Philosophical Society along similar lines. None of the original members was a professor.

So here is what we should do.

Pick a subject you were told was not for you and study it properly. If you were labelled bad at maths, buy a used textbook on probability and work the problems with a pencil. If you were labelled unartistic, draw something every day. Richard Feynman took up drawing in middle age and, by his own account, was bad at it for a long time. He kept going anyway. Being bad at a new thing is not an obstacle. It is the evidence that you are learning.

Read beyond what your job requires. Choose one serious book a year in a field you know nothing about. Follow one scientific controversy far enough that you can explain what each side measured and what each side assumed. Read the original authors and skip the summaries. Keep a notebook and write down what you understood as well as the place where the chapter lost you.

Take ethics away from clergy and slogans and apply it to your own week. Do you tell the truth when it costs you something? Do you keep your standards when everyone around you has lowered theirs? Do you give credit when it is due? Watch yourself for a month and don’t announce that you’re doing it.

Give art real time too. Learn an instrument badly, or sing in a local choir. In a museum, stand in front of one painting until you can say what the painter did with the light. Then go home. One picture truly seen is worth more than forty glanced at.

All of this will cost you socially. Some people will call you pretentious for mentioning a book at dinner. The same people will call you sensible for mentioning a promotion. I’d take the first label. What looks like pretension is often just the awkward early stage of an interest the table doesn’t share, and the way to fix it is to read the next chapter.

Time is the usual objection, and for many people it is a real one. But the hours that build a more open mind are mostly scraps: twenty minutes before the house wakes, a Saturday morning in a library, one evening a week without a screen. Waiting for a sabbatical means waiting for something that never arrives.

None of this needs a patron, a degree, or a sabbatical. It needs a library card and about twenty minutes a day, starting this week.

0 Shares:
In posting, you agree to abide by our guidelines

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Your email address will not be published. Comments are subject to our Community Guidelines. Required fields are marked *

Donate

Our articles are free to read but not free to produce. We are an independent non-profit company and rely on donations and membership subscriptions to maintain our website and the high quality of our publications. If you like what you read, please consider making a donation.

You May Also Like