The following article is an adaptation of William Hagerup’s speech against the motion that ‘Christianity is the basis of Western civilisation’, which was given at a debate in London hosted by the Agora Debate Club on 28 September 2026. For more on that debate, and Agora, see the author’s report here.
Western societies are facing something of an existential crisis of confidence at the moment. Their virtues are questioned, if for very different reasons, by radical, political Islam and by anti-Western, postmodern sections of the left. But in reaction to these, and motivated by a desire to defend what they think are the virtues of the West, we have seen the rise of what is in fact a third threat: the anti-secular, religious right, which claims that Christianity is the foundation and bulwark of Western civilisation and that we need to return to the former if we are to preserve the latter.
Christianism is not the answer
It is important to understand that when an increasing number of especially young people give ‘Christianity’ as the answer, they are in fact asking the right question, namely: ‘How can we preserve what is best about the West?’ But the answer given by the likes of Jordan Peterson and Ayaan Hirsi Ali, that some sort of Christianity is the only solution, is wrong-headed, and potentially just as great a threat to Western values as the existential crisis which prompts the question. Why? Because they are ignoring the most important ingredient in what made the West what it is.
Let’s be clear: Christianity has been extremely important and indeed central to shaping and colouring the edifice that is Western civilisation, but it doesn’t follow that just because something has been important and influential, and perhaps even a force for good in some cases, that it is foundational. To be foundational means to carry the structure built upon it, so let us see why Christianity cannot be the chief loadbearer of Western civilisation.
The first step is to define clearly what the distinguishing features are that set Western civilisation apart from other cultures, including—crucially—other Christian cultures, and make it what it is. I think there are three areas that are key to understanding what is special about ‘the West’. They are: morality, governance, and science (or more broadly, epistemology).
Western morality
On morality, Western civilisation is distinguished by being firmly rooted in the value of the individual. We do not believe it is morally acceptable to sacrifice individuals on the altar of the common good of the collective, except in extreme circumstances such as war. The latter-day evangelists for Christianism may say that this focus on the value of the individual comes from the biblical view of man as created in the image of God and specifically the Reformation and Martin Luther’s focus on salvation by personal faith alone, and there is some truth in that; the Reformation helped to shift the mindset of people in Protestant Europe towards individualism.
And yet, when the Spanish theologian and physician Michael Servetus came to Protestant Geneva—ironically fleeing from Catholic persecution due to his ‘heretical’ beliefs—he was arrested and burned at the stake on 27 October 1553 by the Protestant authorities. His crime was having the ‘wrong’ beliefs, and it is telling that he was burned along with his books. The justification for his execution came from the collectivist and religious mindset which thought that by allowing free speech, heresy would spread like gangrene and bring down God’s wrath upon the entire community. It was better to cut off one sick and expendable limb than harm the entire body.
Some Christians will claim that this was merely a corruption of the ‘real’ Christianity, but the fact is that soon after Christianity became the dominant official religion of the Roman Empire in 380, it became an instrument of state-enforced religious uniformity, deploying the very same tools (legal proscription, property confiscation, capital punishment, and mob violence with official tolerance) against pagans, against Jews, and against dissenting Christians as had been used against themselves previously. So the use of state power to violently persecute and suppress dissenters was an integral part of Christianity as a political-religious power.
Despite reformers within the church, the fundamental change in how we view morality and the moral sanctity of the individual did not take the shape we would recognise today despite nearly two millennia of Christian dominance in Europe. So what happened? I’m coming to that, but let’s look at the second distinguishing feature first.
Western governance
There are slight variations across the Western world, but the key distinguishing features of governance in the West are a belief in the rule of law and limited government accountable to the people and that the legitimacy of a ruler or government comes not from God but from the consent of the people.
Again, many of the latter-day advocates of political Christianity suggest that our democratic institutions, the rule of law, and individual rights all come from the application of biblical principles, that they are derived from the ‘Judeo-Christian’ tradition. But again we run into a similar problem with that claim as the one above: for the first sixteen to seventeen hundred years of the church’s existence and for the first thousand years of its dominance in Europe as a religious-political force to be reckoned with, we did not in fact develop these ideas into anything like the firm shape that is so foundational to the Western political structure.
Even long after the Magna Carta in 1215 instituted some limited checks on royal power, the kings and queens of Europe still claimed they ruled by divine ordinance. And even the very modest step of progress that the Magna Carta represented was resisted by the most senior person in the church, when Pope Innocent III basically cancelled it by issuing a papal bull of annulment in August of the same year. Cancel culture is nothing new, it seems.
Something did happen, long after the Magna Carta, to change the basis of a ruler’s claim to legitimacy, and to create the form of governance we today take for granted. But before I tell you what I think that is, let us finally consider the third distinguishing feature of the West, namely science.
Western science
Technological advances and discoveries of various scientific and mathematical truths certainly happened in other cultures besides Western Europe, such as in India, in China, within the Arab world, and elsewhere. But something happened to propel Europe into the superpower of knowledge that it became, enabling it to race ahead in the curing of diseases and the advancement of technology in a way that no other part of the world did, including—and this is important—the other Christian parts of the world.
Russia, Christian since around the year 988, didn’t develop any of the above by herself, nor did Armenia or Georgia, both Christian lands since the 300s, nor Ethiopia, continuously Christian for nearly 1,700 years. If Christianity were the sufficient foundation of individual morality, democratic governance, and the scientific breakthrough, then we should have seen at least something similar happening in these other Christian lands and regions. But we didn’t. So what did cause these features to emerge and become established as the new normal in the Western part of Christendom?
A new and secular basis
The answer to that question is the Enlightenment. Growing out of the Renaissance’s rediscovery of ancient, pre-Christian Greek and Roman texts and the culture of critical text-reading that this led to, the Enlightenment enabled the learned of the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries to establish two key principles, the first expressed in the Royal Society’s motto, Nullius in verba—take nobody’s word for it—and the second in Immanuel Kant’s sapere aude—dare to know (interestingly, a phrase lifted from the Roman poet Horace, and the literal meaning is closer to ‘dare to be wise’).
The Enlightenment shifted the discussion about morality away from ‘What does God or the Bible say about it?’ to ‘How can we use reason to establish what is morally right and wrong?’ Kant, one of the most central Enlightenment thinkers, said that the human individual is an end in himself, not the means to some other end; not to be thrown on the fire if not useful for that purpose. And Adam Smith, in his A Theory of Moral Sentiments in 1759, tried to establish an entirely nonreligious basis of morality based on human empathy, long before that term became fashionable.
On governance, the Enlightenment thinkers took no one’s word for his or her right to rule. John Locke in the 1680s explicitly rejected the idea that the right to rule comes from God, and in his Second Treatise of Government established the secular principle that legitimate government comes from the consent of the governed. His ideas influenced the establishment of the limited, constitutional monarchy in England and the Declaration of Independence and Constitution of the USA—arguably the greatest examples of secular Enlightenment principles applied to practical politics.
Secular Christians
That’s not to say that Locke was not himself a Christian or that Christianity did not inform his thinking, or that of the many other Enlightenment thinkers, but the crucial thing to note is that they justified proper governance not merely by reference to God and biblical teaching, but to the effect the governance had on individuals and society, including, in Locke’s case, a justification for rebellion that goes directly against what the Apostle Paul said in his letter to the Romans chapter 13: ‘Whosoever therefore resisteth the power [government], resisteth the ordinance of God: and they that resist shall receive to themselves damnation.’
Contrary to this, Locke says that rebellion is justified if the government fails to protect our liberties: ‘…by this breach of trust they forfeit the power the people had put into their hands’, as he explains in chapter XIX of his Second Treatise of Civil Government. The people gave government its power, not God, and the people can justly remove and replace those in power if they fail to protect life and liberty.
Church and state
Many argue that Christianity introduced the separation of church and state, due to the reply Jesus makes in the three synoptic gospels (Matthew, Mark, and Luke) about paying taxes to the Roman overlords: ‘Render therefore unto Caesar the things which are Caesar’s; and unto God the things that are God’s.’ But there are two important things to note about that claim: the first is that Jesus is reported to have given this reply after asking one of the questioners to produce a coin and state whose image is on it. The denarius of Tiberius’s reign would have carried his portrait and, importantly, the inscription ‘Tiberius Caesar, son of the divine Augustus’. For Jews, for whom the worship of graven images is forbidden, the image of someone claiming to be the son of a divine being is not an unimportant consideration, as many theologians have pointed out. This was as such not necessarily about the divide between the sacred and the secular, but about how you negotiate paying tribute to an idol whilst staying true to your own religion.
The second thing to note is that the division between church and state that we in the West today see as perfectly natural did not exist in Christendom for the first sixteen to seventeen hundred years—remember how the early Roman church used the powers of the state to suppress other religions, how the pope intervened in political issues such as the Magna Carta, how the authorities in European countries persecuted ‘heretics’, and not least how Henry VIII had himself declared head of the Church? For sure there existed an increasing distinction between ecclesiastical and temporal law even in the Middle Ages, but the clearer separation of roles and the establishment of a separate, secular realm only came about in a way that we might recognise today with the Enlightenment’s non-religious justifications and broader discussion of the secular role of the government.
To come back to Locke, in his A Letter Concerning Toleration, he argued that ‘The care of souls cannot belong to the civil magistrate, because his power consists only in outward force: but true and saving religion consists in the inward persuasion of the mind, without which nothing can be acceptable to God.’
Did he owe a debt to the Protestant Reformation’s focus on the individual’s relationship with God and salvation by personal faith alone? Absolutely! But as shown in the previous examples, this theology was not sufficient to stop the temporal government imposing the ‘correct’ religion by force, including by the execution of those deemed religiously incorrect.
It was only with the Enlightenment’s insistence on a separate justification and role for the government—the preservation of the individual’s right and liberty, and the maintenance of order—that the promise latent in Protestantism became a political reality.
Secular science
And in science and epistemology, the Royal Society’s motto was particularly apt: take no one’s word for it—whether it was the word of God or the word of Aristotle. The advocates of Christianism will here remind us that many scientists, even during the great Enlightenment, were Christians. That is of course entirely true, but as with John Locke above, what distinguished a scientist during the Enlightenment and since was that he would not justify a single one of his theories by referring to the word of God. Isaac Newton, who was a devoted believer (albeit a ‘heretic’, as he did not believe in the Trinity), never justified the laws of motion or gravity using the Bible as evidence, only arguments from reason and observation. In fact, he instead suggested that such laws of nature as he had discovered are evidence of the existence of some cosmic lawmaker.
As the Oxford physicist and philosopher David Deutsch put it in his book The Beginning of Infinity: ‘The Enlightenment [. . .] was a rebellion against authority [. . .] which set up a tradition of criticism.’ And that was the key element that set in motion an intellectual and societal chemical reaction that fused and created what we today call Western civilisation: with a secular basis of morality, a secular basis of governance, and a secular basis for science.
The secular foundation
Many Christians would concede that Christianity was not sufficient for producing the Enlightened West, but they will say it was necessary, and that it is therefore necessary for its preservation. Shared values, rituals, and celebrations are indeed important for building and maintaining a cohesive society, but although our Christian heritage still plays a part in that, it is a diminishing part. The long-term trend is that people are becoming less, not more, religious, and so it is simply unsustainable to think that we can preserve and build a future West on a religion that not only is relevant for fewer and fewer people, but one that is divided against itself in different dogmatic traditions. As the conservative philosopher Roger Scruton said in his essay Extinguishing the Light, ‘Enlightenment […] has for centuries been intrinsic to Western culture […]’ and ‘Instead of submitting to the demands of religion, enlightened intellectuals devote themselves to truth in general, and the truth about the human world in particular.’
In the Enlightenment tradition, that truth is never a settled Truth, beyond questioning and criticism; the debate is never entirely settled. Christianity, just like many other religions and ideologies, gives final and settled answers to be accepted on faith, and that is why it cannot be the basis for preserving and developing what is best about the West.
Related reading
A reading list against the ‘New Theism’ (and an offer to debate), by Daniel James Sharp
Your email address will not be published. Comments are subject to our Community Guidelines. Required fields are marked *
Donate